Introduction: The Role of Community in Youth Justice

In Australia, the youth justice system is at a critical crossroads. While government initiatives have historically focused on punitive approaches, recent policies have not only stalled progress on reducing Indigenous youth incarceration—they have, in some cases, actively reversed it. However, the solutions for genuine change don’t lie in harsher punishments or expanding detention centres. Instead, they exist within the communities most affected by these issues.

The time has come to reframe how we approach youth justice, putting community-driven solutions at the core of reform. Indigenous-led initiatives, justice reinvestment, and cultural connections are showing far better results than punitive measures. These models not only address the root causes of youth crime but also foster long-term healing and empowerment.

Government Policy Reversals: The Setback in Youth Justice

Despite the rhetoric of closing the gap, many government policies have taken backward steps when it comes to youth justice reform. For example, the lowering of the age of criminal responsibility and reversals on bail laws in Queensland and other regions have worsened the situation. Indigenous youth, already over-represented in the justice system, are being incarcerated at alarming rates, and these policies are directly contributing to that increase.

Reports from the Productivity Commission and other bodies highlight this growing gap between government promises and real outcomes. While some states had made tentative steps toward raising the age of criminal responsibility and reducing Indigenous incarceration rates, recent actions have undone much of that progress. This reflects a failure to listen to the voices of Indigenous leaders and communities who have long called for reforms based on cultural healing and community engagement.

The Success of Community-Led Approaches

While government policies stumble, community-driven approaches are demonstrating real success. Justice reinvestment, for example, focuses on redirecting funds from prisons and detention centres toward community programs that address the underlying causes of youth crime—like poverty, trauma, and lack of educational opportunities.

A key example is the Maranguka Justice Reinvestment Project in Bourke, New South Wales. Through partnerships with local leaders and Indigenous communities, this initiative has shown a significant drop in youth crime, with fewer young people entering the justice system. What makes justice reinvestment effective is its holistic approach: it sees young people not as offenders to be punished, but as community members to be supported. Programs focus on healing trauma, building skills, and strengthening cultural connections, all of which reduce the likelihood of reoffending.

Instead of locking young people away, these programs offer pathways back into the community. By investing in education, mentorship, and cultural programs, justice reinvestment helps prevent youth from entering the system in the first place.

Indigenous-Led Solutions: The Power of Cultural Connection

At the heart of successful community-driven approaches are Indigenous-led solutions, which emphasise cultural knowledge, storytelling, and kinship support. These approaches are based on principles that have guided Indigenous communities for generations: that healing is more powerful than punishment, and that young people thrive when they are connected to their culture, identity, and community.

Programs led by Indigenous Elders and local leaders focus on reconnecting young people to their heritage, providing mentorship, and fostering a sense of belonging. This connection to culture serves as a powerful tool in breaking the cycles of trauma and crime that many Indigenous youth face.

The idea is simple: when young people feel seen, heard, and understood within the context of their culture, they are more likely to engage positively with their communities and avoid the justice system. By empowering Indigenous leaders to take the reins on youth justice programs, we not only honour their deep cultural wisdom but also create solutions that are sustainable, community-centred, and effective.‍

Why Community-Led Solutions Are the Future of Youth Justice

The evidence is clear: community-led solutions work. Programs that focus on restorative justice, cultural healing, and empowerment show far better long-term outcomes than punitive measures like incarceration. But for these programs to continue making a difference, they need consistent support and investment—and this is where governments must change their approach.

Instead of doubling down on policies that entrench disadvantage and increase incarceration rates, governments should focus on scaling up community-based initiatives. The Queensland government's recent $50 million investment in finding the world’s best youth crime solutions presents a unique opportunity to do just that. By working with local leaders, Indigenous thinkers, and successful programs like those developed by the Diagrama Foundation, we can create a youth justice system that focuses on healing, not punishment.

Conclusion: Empowering Communities to Lead the Way

Youth justice in Australia needs a fundamental shift away from punishment and toward community empowerment. Government reversals in youth justice policy are actively harming the progress that was made toward reducing Indigenous incarceration. But the solutions are already here—in the wisdom of Indigenous communities and in the success of programs like justice reinvestment.

By centring community-led approaches and investing in Indigenous-led solutions, we can begin to reverse the cycle of harm that has affected so many young people. This is the future of youth justice: one that is driven by local knowledge, grounded in cultural connection, and focused on creating pathways to healing and success for the next generation.

‍